Blogs

Managing Pokémon Risk – Part I

By Richard Gorvett posted 07-21-2016 13:36

  

You're a university student, walking down a sidewalk in your neighborhood, your eyes fixed intently on your smartphone screen.  You move your phone slowly from side to side, surveying the landscape.  “If there's anything here, I'll find it,” you think to yourself. 


MewTwo.jpgSuddenly, you see something, just ahead and to the left, on the periphery of your screen sensor.  You instinctively shift your direction slightly, and slowly close in on the object.  You switch to virtual camera mode -- and there it is, standing over six-feet tall:  a bi-pedal feline.  Right in front of the window of a well-landscaped brick ranch home, just standing there like he owns the place.  Not believing your luck, you blink and then refocus.  Your eyes were not deceiving you.  It is indeed one of the rarest (and strongest) of the Pokémon:  Mewtwo.  You simply must have it!  But before you attempt the capture, you'd like to get much closer…  

There are, however, some potential problems.  The home's yard is fenced in.  On the fence gate is a large sign:  "No Trespassing.  Beware of Dangerous Dog."  And the Mewtwo appears to be standing in a nicely-manicured flower bed.

Yeah, like any of that is going to keep you from your quarry!


Shattered Window.jpgYou throw open the unlocked gate and step into the yard, breaking your ankle on a loose cobblestone.  Undaunted, you limp purposefully toward the Mewtwo, trampling several expensive flowers and small ornamental shrubs.  You fling your Pokéball, and score a direct hit – the Mewtwo is yours!  In your ecstasy, you raise your arms in triumph, accidentally letting go of your phone, which flies into and shatters a window on the home. 

This awakens the “Dangerous Dog,” a pit bull named Stormy, who jumps out the window at you, trying to defend her turf.  You stagger through the open fence gate and escape out into the street, causing the driver of a passing car to swerve and hit a tree, damaging his car and breaking his wrist. The dog has followed you out the gate and, distracted by all the commotion, locates an easier target, and bites a nearby pedestrian on the sidewalk.

So…

Embedded in this hypothetical scenario are lots of risk and insurance issues.  Let’s start a Student Central dialogue – please respond by commenting and sharing your thoughts on what kinds of insurance policies might cover which damages and injuries.

In a week or two, I’ll come back with a second post, summarizing my own view of some of the scenario’s risk and insurance implications – and perhaps highlighting some of your more perceptive comments!

2 comments
2 views

Comments

08-05-2016 01:06

Pokemon Go Risks and Coverages

Since the temptation of catching Mewtwo was too much to resist and you trespassed on private property you may pose a "criminal mischief" risk to the home owner or renter.  When you broke your ankle you have now created a liability for the homeowner by tripping over their loose cobbletone.  Trampling over landscaping could be considered "vandalism" or "criminal mischief" which would also be the same type of risk associated with the broken window.  The "Dangerous Dog" that you enabled to go free who caused a personal injury would ultimately result bodily injury claims for the homeowner or renter.  You, by running out into the street, causing the automobile accident have created property damage and bodily injury claims for the driver of the car.  Assuming your cell phone screen is shattered upon impact with the window, you would generate a claim for its replacement or repair.  Finally, due to possible breaches in cybersecurity you have put yourself at risk for a cybercrime or identity theft. 

The type of policies that may be able to cover these accidents up to the capped limits would be:

A homeowners or renters policy to cover the damage you did to the window, your broken ankle, and the damage to the landscaping, and possibly even the dog bite depending on the severity of the claim.    ( Dwelling, Personal Property, Personal Liability, Medical Payments, Loss of Use)

A Personal Umbrella Policy purchased by the homeowner to fill in the coverage gaps. Or purchased by you, to provide protection from a loss or lawsuit

An Auto Insurance Policy purchased by the driver of the car would cover the acccident. (Comprehensive, Medical Payments, possibly Custom Parts and Equipment Value, Bodily Injury)

Health Insurance policies for you ( possibly a student policy), for the driver of the car, and the person who was bitten.

If "Dangerous Dog" was in need of any medical attention, his owner  may have purchased pet insurance that could be used to offset the costs

Cellphone insurance purchased by you to repair or replace your damaged device, or your renters insurance if you live in an apartment off-campus and you are not covered under your parents homeowners policy, to cover your personal property

Finally, you could have an additional policy that could cover you in the event that your identity was stolen from playing the game

08-03-2016 12:23

Mewtwo

I would gladly go through all that for a Mewtwo